DEXes · Review
ActiveBlackhole CLMM Review 2026: ve(3,3) Liquidity Hub on Avalanche
Blackhole CLMM is the concentrated-liquidity side of Blackhole, a ve(3,3) decentralized exchange on Avalanche that uses locked BLACK tokens to direct liquidity. It is a young, small protocol with no listed audits, so treat it as higher risk.
By the DappsAtlas editorial team · Updated
DappsAtlas score
5.3/10
Mixed
Our verdict on Blackhole CLMM
5.3/10Blackhole CLMM suits experienced DeFi users on Avalanche who understand ve(3,3) locking, concentrated liquidity and the risk of early-stage protocols. Its main strength is a clear model aimed at launching and deepening liquidity for newer Avalanche tokens. The main caveat is risk: tracking data lists no audits, TVL is only around $2 million, and the protocol is less than a year old. Newcomers should start small, read the docs on locks first, and avoid committing more than they can lose.
Score breakdown
How Blackhole CLMM scores
- Security
- 3.5/10
- Ease of use
- 6.0/10
- Fees
- n/a
- Features
- 6.5/10
Scores run from 0 to 10 and are based only on facts we could verify. Where information was missing we mark the score n/a rather than guess.
What is Blackhole CLMM?
Blackhole is a decentralized exchange on the Avalanche C-Chain that describes itself as a next-generation DEX. Its pitch is to act as a liquidity and trading hub for projects on Avalanche, with a focus on early liquidity for new tokens. The CLMM entry covers its concentrated-liquidity pools.
The design is ve(3,3): users lock the BLACK token to get veBLACK, which is used for governance and for steering incentives. Docs also mention Genesis Pools and Supermassive Locks as core pieces of the system.
Blackhole has been tracked since July 2025 and holds roughly $2 million in total value locked, down slightly over the past week. Tracking data lists no audits. The homepage itself carries little detail, so most of the product information comes from the docs and third-party write-ups. Details such as the team, fee tiers and audits are not published on the homepage.
How Blackhole CLMM works
Blackhole is an automated market maker. Users swap tokens against liquidity pools rather than an order book. Liquidity providers deposit tokens into pools and earn a share of trading fees. In the concentrated-liquidity (CLMM) design, providers pick a price range for their funds, which can raise capital efficiency but needs more active management.
The project follows the ve(3,3) model. Holders lock BLACK to receive veBLACK, which carries governance rights. In this model, veBLACK holders vote on which pools receive token emissions, and pools that attract votes can offer higher rewards to liquidity providers. Docs reference Supermassive Locks as part of this system.
Blackhole also promotes Genesis Pools, aimed at helping new projects launch with initial liquidity on Avalanche. The details of how those pools are configured are in the project's docs, not on the homepage.
6 features
Key features
01
Avalanche-native DEX
Blackhole is built on the Avalanche C-Chain and trades tokens from Avalanche projects, including newer ones.
02
Concentrated liquidity pools
The CLMM pools let liquidity providers concentrate capital inside a price range to earn trading fees more efficiently.
03
ve(3,3) tokenomics
Blackhole uses a vote-escrow model where locked BLACK becomes veBLACK. veBLACK is used for governance and, in this model, for steering rewards.
04
Genesis Pools
Genesis Pools are described as a way for new projects to bootstrap early liquidity at launch.
05
Supermassive Locks
Docs describe Supermassive Locks as part of the locking system that governs veBLACK.
06
Two-token structure
The docs describe two tokens: BLACK as the base token and veBLACK as the governance token obtained by locking.
Pros and cons
What we like
- Native to Avalanche, so it serves projects and users on that chain.
- Concentrated-liquidity pools can give liquidity providers more capital-efficient positions.
- Clear token model: BLACK is locked into veBLACK for governance.
- Genesis Pools target a real gap: bootstrapping liquidity for new token launches.
- Official links and documentation are publicly available.
Watch out for
- No audits are listed for the protocol, so smart-contract risk is unquantified.
- TVL of roughly $2 million is small, so deep trades can move prices and liquidity can leave quickly.
- Ve(3,3) systems depend on token emissions and vote incentives, which can fade and leave liquidity thin.
- The protocol is new (listed since July 2025) and has a limited track record.
- A community thread titled as a list of red flags about the DEX shows some users are sceptical.
- Fee tiers, team details and admin-key arrangements are not published on the homepage.
Blackhole CLMM fees
The homepage does not publish a fee schedule. Swap fees on concentrated-liquidity pools usually vary by pool tier, and users can see the rate for each pool in the app before trading or providing liquidity.
On top of protocol fees, every transaction on Avalanche costs network gas in AVAX. Locking BLACK and voting also involve on-chain transactions, so frequent adjustments add cost.
Is Blackhole CLMM safe?
Tracking data lists no audits for Blackhole, and the homepage does not mention any. Without published audit reports, smart-contract risk can't be assessed from outside. Admin-key and upgrade arrangements are also not described on the homepage.
The protocol is non-custodial in the usual DEX sense: users keep funds in their own wallets and interact through smart contracts. That removes exchange custody risk but not contract, oracle or liquidity risk. A community thread listing red flags about the DEX exists, which is worth reading critically alongside the official docs.
Always confirm the website address against the docs' official links page to avoid imitation sites. Liquidity provision and token locking can lead to losses, including impermanent loss and price drops in BLACK.
6 steps
How to get started with Blackhole CLMM
- 1
Open the official site and confirm the address against the official links page in the docs.
- 2
Set up an Avalanche-compatible wallet and fund it with AVAX for gas.
- 3
Read the docs on BLACK, veBLACK and locks before buying or locking any tokens.
- 4
Start with a small swap to check pricing, slippage and fees shown in the app.
- 5
If you want to provide liquidity, choose a pool and a price range, and understand that a position can stop earning when the price leaves the range.
- 6
Monitor positions and any lock periods, and only commit funds you can afford to lose.
Who Blackhole CLMM is for
Blackhole is for Avalanche users comfortable with ve(3,3) mechanics who want to trade newer tokens or provide concentrated liquidity. It also targets project teams looking for early liquidity. Beginners and anyone who needs audited, long-running infrastructure should be cautious.
Blackhole CLMM FAQs
What is Blackhole CLMM?
Blackhole is a decentralized exchange on the Avalanche C-Chain that follows the ve(3,3) model. It aims to give new Web3 projects early liquidity through mechanisms such as Genesis Pools. The CLMM entry covers its concentrated-liquidity pools.
What is the BLACK token used for?
BLACK is the protocol's token. Holders can vote-escrow it into veBLACK, which is used for governance. Locking is how holders take part in directing emissions and rewards.
Has Blackhole been audited?
Tracking data lists no audits for the protocol. That does not prove the code is unsafe, but it means there is no independent review to point to. Check the official docs for any audit reports before depositing.
What does CLMM mean?
Concentrated liquidity lets providers supply funds within a chosen price range instead of across all prices. This can earn more fees per dollar while the price stays in range. It also means the position stops earning if the price moves outside the range, and impermanent loss can be larger.
Is Blackhole safe to use?
The protocol's tracked TVL is under $2 million, and the tracker shows 0 listed audits. Both point to higher risk than larger, long-running DEXes. Only commit money you can afford to lose, and read the official docs first.
What are the fees on Blackhole?
The homepage does not publish fee tiers. Swap fees and pool-specific rates are shown in the app and docs. Avalanche gas fees apply to every transaction.
Compare
Blackhole CLMM alternatives
Uniswap V3 is a non-custodial decentralized exchange protocol for token swaps and concentrated liquidity provision across 40+ chains.
Uniswap V4 is the latest Uniswap DEX version with hooks and concentrated liquidity, running on 22 chains for self-custody token swaps and liquidity provision.
Uniswap V2 is a non-custodial automated market maker DEX on 17 chains for token swaps and liquidity provision, with about $938M TVL.
THORChain is a Layer 1 DEX for swapping native assets across blockchains without wrapped tokens or bridges, aimed at self-custody and no-KYC users.
SushiSwap is a multichain decentralized exchange with a swap aggregator, perps, staking and liquidity pools for self-custody DeFi traders.
Balancer V2 is a non-custodial AMM protocol for programmable liquidity pools on Ethereum and eight other EVM chains, aimed at traders and liquidity providers.
Same category
More DEXes
Curve is a decentralized exchange on Ethereum built for low-slippage swaps of stablecoins and similar assets, with CRV governance and a crvUSD stablecoin.
PancakeSwap is a BNB Smart Chain decentralized exchange with swaps, farming, staking and CAKE governance for self-custody DeFi users.
PancakeSwap AMM V3 is a multichain decentralized exchange using concentrated liquidity pools, for traders and liquidity providers, led by BNB Chain.
PancakeSwap V2 is a constant-product AMM DEX mainly on BNB Chain for swapping tokens, providing liquidity and farming CAKE rewards.
Raydium is a decentralized exchange and automated market maker on Solana, built around fast, low-cost swaps and liquidity pools.
QuickSwap is a multichain DEX, started on Polygon, offering swaps, liquidity pools, farms, QUICK staking and perpetuals for self-custody DeFi users.
Same chain
More on Avalanche
Aave V3 is a non-custodial DeFi lending protocol on 21 chains where users earn interest on deposits or borrow against collateral.
OKX is a major centralized crypto exchange for spot and derivatives trading, earn products and a Web3 wallet, with its own OKB token.
LayerZero V2 is a cross-chain messaging protocol and bridge infrastructure for developers and asset issuers, connecting dozens of blockchains.
Morpho Blue is a permissionless lending primitive with about $11.4 billion in TVL on DefiLlama, accessed mainly through curated vaults.
Euler V2 is a modular DeFi lending protocol for lenders, borrowers and market curators, with about $268M TVL across 16 chains.
Across is an intent-based cross-chain bridge and swap protocol for moving tokens between Ethereum, rollups and other chains, with an API for apps.
How we checked
Sources
Last updated . Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it.